Can Big Business Be Both Profitable & Principled? Maybe Not
Jerry Greenfield co-founder of Ben & Jerry’s ice-cream, one of the world’s most iconic brands, has cut ties with the company after…
September 24, 2025
The recently released WA Auditor General’s report for 2025, exposed not only serious misconduct in Development WA in previous years but placed a telling disclaimer on its findings.
The WA Auditor General Caroline Spencer said: “It is disappointing to have to issue disclaimers due to a lack of evidence as the inability of an auditor to access the information they need to meet their obligation is a serious matter for the auditor and for those who rely on their opinion . . . To best serve the Parliament, community and public interest, we encourage all ministers to choose openness and disclosure as their default position, rather than seeking to identify rationale for not providing information.”
This disclaimer cannot be underestimated. This points to the Government withholding information, with departments restricting access to transactional documents, allowing those agencies and the Government to manage the risk to their reputation or possibly conceal unlawful activity.
Indeed, the WA Auditor General said further in a radio interview that there would have been fraud during the period in question. A staggering statement, especially given the Auditor General’s office was not provided with the necessary documentation to thoroughly investigate it so could not effectively carry out their job, and uncover that fraud.
The real question is, where is the accountability when the government department is evasive and refuses to supply information?
Despite robust rules and oversight frameworks, there is an ongoing recurrence of integrity breaches within Australia’s government, private companies, and now even the national corruption watchdog reflecting a deeper and much more complex issue rooted in human behaviour permeating across our governing institutions and businesses.
Call it familiarity, blind loyalty, or simply bypassing procedure, issues like the recent case of the National Anti-Corruption Commission (NACC) mishandling a complaint against its commissioner are the latest examples of systemic procedural and integrity failures across Australia’s anti-corruption ecosystem.
This case exposed failings within the agency regarding its lack of transparency. When the NACC chose to self-regulate, it failed to follow its own rules and procedures, causing a breach of legal duty in its oversight role.
Legislation and policy are developed not as mere suggestions but to provide clear guardrails for decision-making in government and business and behaviour that echoes community expectations.
Common themes are emerging across the country.
No organisation is immune to human error or mis-judgements. But while the identified issues are presented simply as human error, they appear systemic and entrenched in cultures, where robust frameworks exist but are not followed or effectively enforced.
One would expect that our corruption watchdogs nationwide would be hypervigilant to ensure that smaller transgressions within their institutions, like “bending the rules — just this once”, don’t become systemic and are not allowed to become the norm. But also, that these staff, no matter their rank or seniority in the organisation, are reminded that the process is there for a reason, and to bypass these is a clear misstep.
Reform is not just necessary; it’s urgent. These behavioural patterns within government and the institutions designed to uphold integrity have revealed that no framework is immune to the flaws of the human condition. Legislation, rules, policies, or oversight mechanisms are only as effective as those enforcing them. Oversight mechanisms must be robust, responsive, and ready to trigger immediate and meaningful action whenever a procedural lapse is uncovered and ignored. Accountability cannot be optional; it must be swift and unequivocal.
But true reform goes beyond policy, action and counteraction. It demands a shift in organisational culture and particularly in leadership. Transparency, courage, and self-scrutiny must be embraced not as ideals, but as essential practices, embedded as deeply as any compliance framework.
To restore public trust, behavioural accountability must be as rigorously enforced as procedural rules, in all levels of an organisation.
Without this balance, integrity watchdogs risk becoming reflections of the very failures they were designed to prevent.
Ultimately, the Australian public deserves to have the confidence that our government, public and private institutions are not only subject to external audit but also have the courage to face investigation when probity is in question.
If there is nothing to hide, let them look.
It’s time for humility and courage to permeate our oversight institutions.
Increasing transparency, addressing the reluctance of government departments to co-operate with investigations or oversight, enforcing accountability and fostering a culture of co-operation are the most immediate critical steps that must be taken towards restoring public trust and ensuring effective governance.
Donna Bates is an integrity expert.
First published in The West Australian on 20 June 2025.
Donna speaks on accountability, transparency and organisational culture at conferences, board days and team workshops. Find out more about her speaking and workshops on integrity.

Donna Bates
Donna Bates is a Strategic Planning Consultant, a media commentator, keynote speaker and integrity-led board advisor with 28+ years’ experience across corporate, government and community sectors. She helps boards, CEOs and senior leaders close the gap between where the organisation is and where it needs to be, with strategy grounded in values, not hype.
A no-pressure conversation. Donna listens, to what you’re facing, and to what sits beneath it. No pitch. No obligation. Just clarity about whether and how she can help.
Book Your Clarity Call
Jerry Greenfield co-founder of Ben & Jerry’s ice-cream, one of the world’s most iconic brands, has cut ties with the company after…
September 24, 2025
The report from the special inquiry into the 2025 WA State election signals a landmark moment in WA’s electoral history, given the…
August 29, 2025